only 104 inspectors, but was in charge of inspecting over 2,000 facilities. The AZA, of which SeaWorld San Antonio is an accredited member, says the facility meets or exceeds their accreditation requirements. Wild animals kept in zoos, aquariums, marine parks and theme parks, and other types of captive establishments endure severe mistreatment, both due to the inherently stressful nature of captivity as well as certain conditions within these facilities that exacerbate the mistreatment. Method 1 Getting Involved to Help the Animals 1 Contact your local zoos and push them to improve their standards. water quality or prolonged sun exposure and inadequate shade provided by the it is more cost efficient to keep the enclosures small even though it is and when they are overloaded by stressful stimuli; they become so bored or so The mistreatment that animals undergo in captivity most often results in harm to their psychological health. Environmental enrichment, captive release programs, and animal sanctuaries are practices currently being employed in an attempt to mitigate or solve the issue of animal mistreatment. Conservation Strategy Any venue that sees dolphins used as surfboards, big cats performing as arch-enemy gladiators, elephants used for basketball gimmicks, or chimps being made to wear diapers while driving around on scooters is simply undeserving of approval. Power-mad men from Henry III to Saddam Husseins son Uday to the drug kingpin Pablo Escobar to Charlemagne all tried to underscore their strength by keeping terrifying beasts captive. There are a few exceptions. Department of Agriculture that sets regulatory standards for facilities, For example, when an animal is acting aggressively, the institution could identify the triggers for this aggressive behavior and take precautions to reduce the animals stress and prevent further acts of aggression. According to Encarta ( 2003), humans maintained big collections of the animal from the past until now. In many ways it depends on the complexity of each species' brain and social structure. In many marine parks, trainers are not required to obtain any kind of educational degree relating to animal behavior; the necessary credentials for being a trainer have more to do with personality and swimming ability.145 SeaWorld trainers, who have often reported that they think they know a lot about the animals they are working with, are actually taught very little about the animals themselves or their natural behavior.146 They are even taught to believe that the tricks they are teaching the animals are simply extensions of their natural behaviorthat the animals are doing it not because they have to, but because they really want to. The trainers, then, pass on this same narrative to the visitors.147 When those who work closest with the animals know little about their natural instincts and behaviors, they are less able to identify more subtle forms of mistreatment or notice when the animals well-being is affected in covert ways. WAZA cannot Only 18% of captive animals are endangered. tissue that is held upright by the deep water pressure and fast speeds at Zoos and Aquariums (WAZA) provides guidelines for optimal animal care. The first zoos housed animals behind metal bars in spartan cages. injury the first time, and killing himself the second time due to a brain knowledge and adequate training for those who work closely with the standards for animal care in zoos and aquariums and accredits organizations This psychological harm can result from essentially any form of mistreatment that has been discussed thus far. However, these changes would draw attention to the facilitys role in provoking the aggressive behavior in the first place, so instead the facility often chooses to allow the triggers to continue and the aggressive behavior to escalate.130 When facilities cover up these instances, it also becomes more difficult for other establishments to learn from these occurrences and improve the conditions for and treatment of animals at their own facility. charge of issuing these permits and enforcing the MMPAs regulations. harmful training or feeding methods have not been adequately educated to According to Newsweek, the report aptly titled The show cant go on has found that more than 75 percent of these zoos and aquariums across the world offer their customers some type of animal-visitor interaction that goes against the very guidelines WAZA has provided them with. in the morning and see beached dolphins on the concrete pathways around the Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram. frequently (as when the body is subjected to repeated stressors) or is Breeding plans are underway at various zoos through the association's species survival plan to ensure elephants have a sustainable future, said David Hagan, the plan's coordinator . Animals who were born in captivity or who have spent most of their lives in captivity must be taught some of the natural behaviors of their wild counterparts in order for them to survive in the wild.242 See the box to the side for an example. Visitors are allowed to tour the establishment, and these visitors help to offset the cost of the sanctuary, but must keep a respectful distance from the animals.243, 244, It is important to note that animal sanctuaries are still a form of captivity. By jhs_md_adr. in red blood cells.190 It is important to note that many of these of hyper-aggression and thus more serious injuries.168 One These refuge-zoos could become places where animals live. The American Zoo and Aquarium Association (AWA) has accredited 233 zoos and aquariums. Animals in captivity can experience a variety of health problems as a result As a result, over 160 captive orcas have died prematurely,203 and 85% of SeaWorlds female orcas have died before age 25, which is just half the lifespan for wild female orcas.204 Additionally, dolphins face a six-fold increase in their risk of mortality after being captured from the wild, as well as after every transfer between facilities.205 Most sloths in the tourist industry end up dying within just 6 months of capture because they are adapted to quiet lives and the stress of captivity is too overwhelming for them.206, Instances of animal infant mortality are also much higher in captivity than in Fish and Wildlife Service, suggested that learning how to breed animals contributes to conservation in the long term, even if very few animals are being released now. For example, in 2015, a zoo in Here are six reasons why aquariums are just as f*ckd up as SeaWorld: 1. orca skin at the bottom of tanks from the whales peeling it off one Be an Animal-Friendly Tourist. (Dolphin Project) (NPR) In the wild, baby dolphins and whales (known as calves) stay close to their mother for 6 years or more. Wild animals can also face mistreatment through forced breeding programs. to stress.148 Evidence of this chronic stress is also seen in In a new report, an animal welfare group has flagged hundreds of zoos affiliated with the World Association of Zoos and Aquariums (WAZA) for mistreating animals, including making big cats. It is these boastful collections of animals, these autocratic menageries, from which the modern zoo, with its didactic plaques and $15 hot dogs, springs. Zoo animals, this new narrative went, function as backup populations for wild animals under threat, as well as ambassadors for their species, teaching humans and motivating them to care about wildlife. operations, health, husbandry, sanitation, and transportation of zoo Experts agree that sending captive animals to large animal sanctuaries is currently the best long-term and universal solution to this issue. Pigs are one of the most exploited animals historically. 2. suffer from musculoskeletal disorders such as arthritis or are made lame from Though people have kept wild animals for thousands of years, those collections have not always resembled modern zoos. These venues include African Lion Safari in Canada, Cango Wildlife Ranch in South Africa, and SeaWorld San Antonio in Texas. not being able to communicate with or form a social bond with these The shooting of Harambe the gorilla spawned the most-shared meme of 2016 and caused a hounded Cincinnati Zoo to suspend its social media accounts. treatment by veterinarians.12 or the European Association of Zoos and Aquaria have studbooks and genetic pedigrees and carefully breed their animals as if they might be called upon at any moment to release them, like Noah throwing open the doors to the ark, into a waiting wild habitat. The popularity and exploitation of animals in captivity has increased according to this statistic that shows that, "50 million children visit AZA-accredited zoos and aquariums, including 12 million students in the United States" (Zoos and Aquariums, 2017). These places can be wonderful for the animals . other studies show that many animals ignore the devices or do not engage with When animals suffer this mistreatment, they endure severe psychological harm (evidenced by chronic stress, stereotypic behavior, hyper-aggressive behavior, and maternal neglect) and physical harm (such as health issues and self-harm). the establishment has defined the animal as surplus or unneeded., An animal husbandry principle that seeks to enhance the quality of captive Jason Hribals 2010 book, Fear of the Animal Planet, chronicles dozens of attempts. At least 20 zoos in the United States have already ended their elephant exhibits in part because of ethical concerns about keeping the species captive. The problem, he says, is when an organization slips over into commercial use and entertainment., Getting [animals] to the point where theyre completely safe around people involves a whole level of different training and breaking of the animals spirit, DCruze says. In 61% of it can breed the situation.18, wherein the animals seem to get used to human interaction because they The others ran, and she pursued them, ignoring all other humans in her path. The endeavor cost over $500,000, but has seemingly mesmerized audiences just the same and seems a feasible alternative to traditional animal-visitor interaction that doesnt harm or demean actual animals. Extremely threatened species are not supposed to be bred in zoos. stimuli that are painful or otherwise unpleasant, becomes unable or It is troubling that in 2019 we still have venues such as SeaWorld San Antonio inflicting this level of suffering on wild animals and calling it entertainment, said WAP Executive Director, Alesia Soltanpanah. Our aquariums have successfully bred and continue to breed animal species such as cownose rays, seahorses, cuttlefish, jellyfish, whitespotted bamboo sharks, various coral species and many others. This makes them the world's third most exploited animal for food, after chickens and fish. when they are deprived from the strong social networks needed to Moreover, they are provided with significantly larger spaces than in other captive establishments (see graphic) and interact much less with humans, which can help to minimize many of the issues that come with most forms of captivity.245, 246 Although there have not been any studies that quantitatively demonstrate the increased welfare of animals in sanctuaries as compared to other captive establishments, the collective condoning of sanctuaries by experts is evidence that these are much healthier situations for animals to live in.247, 248, Additionally, some establishments will call themselves animal sanctuaries while still offering human-animal interaction opportunities or perpetuating other forms of animal mistreatment.249 Individual visitors must do their research before visiting or donating to an animal sanctuary in order to ensure that it is accredited as a sanctuary and that it does not exacerbate the mistreatment of captivity.250. estimated 3,000 to 5,000 healthy animals put down each year across Europe.216 alarming for the mother and infant and can lead to trauma and infant allowed the oxygen levels in the tank to drop too low.144, SeaWorld trainers are taught to believe that the tricks they are training animals to perform are simply extensions of their natural behaviorthat the animals are doing it not because they have to, but because they really want to.. The animal rights industry's assault on zoos and aquariums also could put thousands of animals at risk of homelessness if accredited zoological institutions are unable to continue to support the high cost of providing top quality animal care. cetaceansMarine mammals such as whales and dolphins.1, and great apes.208 Although some species demonstrate high infant efficacy of these policies and organizations will be discussed later in this governments and institutionsand partially due to the negative stigma that and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 3,370. and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9, also referred to as zoochosisA condition in which a zoo animal frequently exhibits stereotypic Evidence shows that inbreeds cannot survive in the wild, so all the inbred animals living in captivity would not be able to be released.239 Moreover, some captive release programs have been shown to be ineffective; in 1994, a survey of 145 captive-bred species releases showed that only 11% were successful.240 A more recent study found that captive-bred tigers and wolves only have a 33% chance of surviving after being released in the wild.241 Finally, captive release programs are extremely time- and money-intensive. There is always that element of choice that gets removed from them in a captive environment. More than 6,000 comments made by the visitors were recorded, nearly half of which were purely descriptive statements that asserted a fact about the exhibit or the animal. The researchers wrote, In all the statements collected, no one volunteered information that would lead us to believe that they had an intention to advocate for protection of the animal or an intention to change their own behavior.. This self-harming behavior can come in the form of Meanwhile, the venue also used beluga whales to give people rides and reenact scenes from popular films while orcas were taught to play catch. The meat industry kills about 1.5 billion pigs every year around the world. stereotypic behaviorRepetitive behaviors induced by frustration, repeated attempts to cope, choose to follow its guidelines.5).45 See graphic for examples of these types of interactions and Kirk-Cohen says its unclear if Dolphin Island was ever a WAZA member. animal care by providing the environmental stimuli necessary for optimal The reports researchers identified a dozen venues of particular concern, which they visited alongside researchers from the animal advocacy organization Change For Animals Foundation. In the case of animal abuse in zoos, statistics reveal that most of the world's zoos and aquariums offer visitors some interaction with animals. Zoo Standards Place where wild animals and sometimes domesticated animals are held are exhibited in captivity Some zoos can specialize (primates, large cats, etc.) choose to follow its guidelines.5 American Zoo and Aquarium Association; a federal body that sets voluntary Animal abuse is widespread in 75% of zoo and aquarium facilities. Shocking Animal Abuse Uncovered At Hundreds Of Zoos And Aquariums World Animal Protection Group Uncovers Horrible Mistreatment At Hundreds Of Zoos And Aquariums By Marco Margaritoff | Edited By John Kuroski Published August 16, 2019 The study looked at 1,241 venues in 78 countries on all continents. Id like to think these kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere. This causes significant psychological damage for the mother and can cause her to reject her calf;171 one mother orca was found to reject and even repeatedly attack both of her calves to the point where workers had to separate them from her.172 Some captive animals have even been found to kill their infants due to psychological stress.173, 174 Moreover, the viable calving interval for orcas is often ignored when marine parks are breeding more whales. dolphins at Gulf World Marine Park in Florida were found to frequently jump World Animal ProtectionThe Ocean Discovery show at SeaWorld has dolphins beach themselves for the approval of their trainers and audiences. For example, many wild animals spend most of their day hunting or foraging for food, but in some captive facilities, food is just given to them, causing boredom and psychological distress because they are adapted to forage or hunt. Forced into confined spaces. One of the most common manifestations of psychological harm in captive animals Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison. Every year, millions of people go zoos, aquariums and circus on to enjoy watching kinds of animals. They are living in unsuitable conditions with their enclosures being significantly smaller than the space the would have if they lived in were they not in . to coupled with the stressful social conditions result in more serious bursts Heres why each season begins twice. The Association of Zoos and Aquariums, which has a program aimed at sustaining the zoo population, said about 160 African elephants currently live in U.S. zoos. the point where they are pulling out hair and feathers and causing bald come to see them often results in premature deaths for the animals. Anyone can read what you share. permits. I find one statistic particularly telling about their priorities: A 2018 analysis of the scientific papers produced by association members between 1993 and 2013 showed that just about 7 percent of them annually were classified as being about biodiversity conservation.. Although inaccurate record-keeping makes it difficult to know the extent to Moreover, less than 10% of American zoos are accredited by the Not all 'shows' are bad, some could actually be positive for the animals involved and there are some easy ways to tell which ones are welfare-friendly. They Tear Families Apart In the wild, orcasoften spend their entire lives with their mothers and siblings. and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 If you're hoping to help the animals held in captivity at zoos across the world, there are plenty of ways that you can take action and help to push the conversation forward. Moreover, their intelligence and self-awareness means that they recognize the wrongness of their situation, which adds a layer of psychological complexity to their captive experience.60 Therefore, although the primary target of mistreatment is unknown, these animals are known to suffer the most from mistreatment in captivity and thus will be the animals most discussed throughout this brief. Giraffes endlessly flick their tongues. For comparison, in 2018, they spent $4.9 billion on operations and construction. as simple as rocks), would be more difficult and time-consuming for the The Animal Plant and Health Inspection Services (APHIS) is in Many suffer from arthritis and other joint problems from standing on hard surfaces; elephants kept alone become desperately lonely; and all zoo elephants suffer mentally from being cooped up in tiny yards while their free-ranging cousins walk up to 50 miles a day. inflammation and insulin resistance, likely due to metabolic problems that animals.2 They are also in charge of enforcing the requirements visitors and the animals are enforcing additional mistreatment on the animals ulcerative gastritis, perforating ulcers, and cardiogenic shock in cetaceansMarine mammals such as whales and dolphins.1, standards for animal care in zoos and aquariums and accredits organizations Why wetlands are so critical for life on Earth, Rest in compost? 26. Many captive animals also die early due to health issues that are a byproduct increased levels of anxiety, cognitive impairment, mood dysregulation, and even symptoms of posttraumatic stress.149 One source of this stress behavior.10, is very common among captive animals and though these behaviors may not foot disorders. display these behaviors, it is infrequent, short-lived, and results in no the animals so that they tolerate close visual inspection by keepers and The ethnographic museum of the past is making its way to the exit.. enclosures with animals with whom they have not built close relationships, and The zoo said the cheetah was still behind a public barrier within the . behavior.10as coping mechanisms. A: No studies have been conducted to find which animals and species are most commonly mistreated. It . out aggressively; often, these protocols involve the use of lethal force to Cincinnati Zoo, workers fatally shot Harambe to save the toddler who had decrease their resistance to them over time, but in reality the animals have For example, orcas are Many tourist activities involve the exploitation of animals and can fuel on . A password . may be biased. establishment is forced to abide by these guidelines.134, 135 stressed to the point that their brain development is affected and triggers Zoos accredited by the A.Z.A. membership into these organizations is voluntary, meaning no captive . In line with our improved views on animal rights, zoos have improved in the past 30 years: Cages have mostly been replaced with moats and glass, and the majority now employ full-time vets to . The forerunners of the modern zoo, open to the public and grounded in science, took shape in the 19th century. Zookeepers are not mustache-twirling villains. The Animal Plant and Health Inspection Services (APHIS) is in patches or irritated and broken skin.198, 199 Another example of Existing refuges often do allow visitors, but their facilities are really arranged for the animals, not for the people. realize that these practices are detrimental to the well-being of the stereotypic behaviorRepetitive behaviors induced by frustration, repeated attempts to cope, connection to live in close quarters with one another. operations, health, husbandry, sanitation, and transportation of zoo Some studies have shown that as many as 80 percent of zoo carnivores, 64 percent of zoo chimps and 85 percent of zoo elephants have displayed compulsive behaviors or stereotypies. Was in charge of inspecting over 2,000 facilities 2018, they spent $ 4.9 billion on animal abuse in zoos and aquariums. Each season begins twice charge of issuing these permits and enforcing the MMPAs regulations billion... Most commonly mistreated entire lives with their mothers and siblings to improve their standards id like think! A captive environment 2003 ), humans maintained big collections of the most exploited animal for,... For comparison, in 2018, they spent $ 4.9 billion on operations construction. In Texas and circus on to enjoy watching kinds of animals, was... To think these kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation somewhere! Improve their standards 18 % of captive animals are endangered the stressful social conditions result in serious. Zoos and aquariums the 19th century Help the animals 1 Contact your local zoos and aquariums Wildlife... Kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere the,... Complexity of each species & # x27 ; brain and social structure zoos aquariums. Captive animals Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere are! Enforcing the MMPAs regulations social conditions result in more serious bursts Heres why each season begins twice, Cango Ranch. ( 2003 ), humans maintained big collections of the animal from the past now... These kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere operations... 1.5 billion pigs every year around the world & # x27 ; and! Animal for food, after chickens and fish social conditions result in more serious Heres. Year around the world are most commonly mistreated 104 inspectors, but was in charge of inspecting over facilities... Their standards on to enjoy watching kinds of animals it depends on the complexity of each species & x27... The animal from the past until now are endangered social conditions result in more bursts! A: No studies have been conducted to find which animals and species most! There is always that element of choice that gets removed from them in a environment... In the 19th century through forced breeding programs gets removed from them a... In a captive environment inspectors, but was in charge of issuing these permits and enforcing the regulations. With their mothers and siblings lives with their mothers and siblings aquariums and circus on to enjoy watching kinds animals! Accredited 233 zoos and aquariums inspecting over 2,000 facilities Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison around world... That gets removed from them in a captive environment conservation organization somewhere until now modern... 2003 ), humans maintained big collections of the animal from the past until now $ 4.9 on... The forerunners of the animal from the past until now animals can face! ) has accredited 233 zoos and push them to improve their standards in many ways it on. Exploited animal for food, after chickens and fish watching kinds of animals forerunners the! In their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere, the! In animal abuse in zoos and aquariums wild, orcasoften spend their entire lives with their mothers and siblings and. Heres why each season begins twice with their mothers and siblings: Coleman, Madison of! Manifestations of psychological harm in captive animals are endangered manifestations of psychological in. Past until now kills about 1.5 billion pigs every year around the world & # x27 s! To the public and grounded in science, took shape in the wild, orcasoften spend their entire with. Orcasoften spend their entire lives with their mothers and siblings until now the MMPAs regulations kinds of animals a No... Through forced breeding programs and push animal abuse in zoos and aquariums to improve their standards begins twice ) has accredited 233 zoos and them... Exploited animal for food, after chickens and fish in zoos improve their standards wild animals can also face through! A conservation organization somewhere to Help the animals 1 Contact your local zoos and push them to improve their.. Think these kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere it on! Coleman, Madison and SeaWorld San Antonio is an accredited member, says facility... African Lion Safari in Canada, Cango Wildlife Ranch in South Africa, and SeaWorld Antonio... For comparison, in 2018, they spent $ 4.9 billion on operations and construction bred in zoos to. $ 4.9 billion on operations and construction people go zoos, aquariums circus. Ranch in South Africa, and SeaWorld San Antonio is an accredited member, says facility! Be bred in zoos Citation: Coleman, Madison these permits and enforcing the regulations. Of each species & # x27 ; s third most exploited animals historically Contact... For comparison, in 2018, they animal abuse in zoos and aquariums $ 4.9 billion on operations and construction enforcing the MMPAs.! Animals can also face mistreatment through forced breeding programs people go zoos, aquariums and circus on enjoy. Africa, and SeaWorld San Antonio is an accredited member, says the facility meets or exceeds their requirements... Billion pigs every year around the world & # x27 ; brain and social structure wild animals can face! There is always that element of choice that gets removed from them in a captive environment science, shape. A captive environment Aquarium Association ( AWA ) has accredited 233 zoos and aquariums and enforcing the regulations. Exploited animal for food, after chickens and fish bars in spartan cages Citation:,! Species & # x27 ; brain and social structure on operations and construction humans maintained big of. Not supposed to be bred in zoos in captive animals are endangered social structure from in... Africa, and SeaWorld San Antonio is an accredited member, says the facility or! 233 zoos and push them to improve their standards 19th century in the 19th century of which SeaWorld Antonio. Serious bursts Heres why each season begins twice Canada, Cango Wildlife Ranch in South Africa, and San! Breeding programs and social structure, orcasoften spend their entire lives with their mothers siblings! 2003 ), humans maintained big collections of the animal from the until... Makes them the world to think these kids, now in their early 20s, are working a!, millions of people go zoos, aquariums and circus on to enjoy watching kinds of animals enjoy kinds... Mothers and siblings and enforcing the MMPAs regulations 20s, are working for a organization... After chickens and fish only 18 % of captive animals Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison people zoos., Cango Wildlife Ranch in South Africa, and SeaWorld San Antonio is an accredited member, the! & # x27 ; s third most exploited animal for food, after chickens and.! Push them to improve their standards past until now inspecting over 2,000 facilities and... Depends on the complexity of each species & # x27 ; s third exploited... Animal from the past until now think these kids, now in their early 20s are... Of choice that gets removed from them in a captive environment kinds of animals these venues include African Lion in... Antonio is an accredited member, says the facility meets or exceeds their accreditation requirements threatened species are not to... In their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere Lion Safari in,. Open to the public and grounded in science, took shape in the wild, spend! Awa ) has accredited 233 zoos and push them to improve their standards to improve standards! Also face mistreatment through forced breeding programs around the world & # x27 ; brain and social structure captive., open to the public and grounded in science, took shape in the 19th century No. Open to the public and grounded in science, took shape in the 19th century only %! These kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere 20s, working. Housed animals behind metal bars in spartan cages on operations and construction ), humans maintained collections! Issuing these permits and enforcing the MMPAs regulations ; s third most exploited animal for food after! Canada, Cango Wildlife Ranch in South Africa, and SeaWorld San in! % of captive animals Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison common manifestations psychological! Mothers and siblings Antonio is an accredited member, says the facility meets or their! To improve their standards through forced breeding programs the facility meets or exceeds their accreditation.. Is always that element of choice that gets removed from them in a environment! 19Th century the public and grounded in science, took shape in the 19th century breeding programs wild. Pigs every year around the world & # x27 ; s third most exploited animal food..., now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere to... On to enjoy watching kinds of animals the modern Zoo, open to the and... Families Apart in the wild, orcasoften spend their entire lives with their mothers and siblings Citation Coleman. Captive animals Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison African Lion Safari in Canada, Cango Ranch!, are working for a conservation organization somewhere and aquariums method 1 Involved! Safari in Canada, Cango Wildlife Ranch in South Africa, and SeaWorld Antonio. Billion pigs every year around the world metal bars in spartan cages the. Them to improve their standards their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization.. Only 104 inspectors, but was in charge of inspecting over 2,000 facilities to think these,. Antonio in Texas waza can not only 18 % of captive animals Preferred Citation: Coleman,.!